Would You Privatize Defense?

Timothy Noah of Slate wrote this article yesterday about the case for socialized healthcare. It’s an allegorical tale of an America with privatized national defense. People who place a high value on defense (and have the money for higher premiums) would be able to afford the best defense plans, and the people with little money or inclination to put toward defense would have less expensive premiums, but higher out-of-pocket costs for paying the militia to defend them against attack. Those people living in cities that have already been attacked (Baltimore, Honolulu, Washington DC and New York) would basically be uninsurable, because the defense insurance companies would place them in a very high risk category.

Sound familiar?

This is the way the political left needs to start framing these discussions if they’re going to make people understand that healthcare, like national defense, isn’t a privilege. It’s a right. It’s a moral responsibility of the government to care for its people. Everyone, regardless of income, deserves the same access to heathcare.

In our current system, costs are skyrocketing. The system is broken, and needs to be fixed. We’re the wealthiest nation on earth, yet the only nation of its kind with this kind of healthcare system. What’s wrong with us?


8 thoughts on “Would You Privatize Defense?

  1. rockingjude says:

    LOLLLL…as it was meant to be..One can’t argue with facts..and each of those lines were pulled out of the Bill…
    I rest my case…))


  2. longhawl says:

    Brian, your use of “general welfare” is more in line with the views of current progressives rather than that of the Constitutional framers. They did not intend that Congress should spend money to meet all the needs (rights?) of the people but only to execute the duties given to the Federal government by the Constitution and secure the general welfare through these granted duties. In particular see Article I, Section 8.

    Nowhere did the framers give Congress the power enact legislation for the general welfare beyond their powers, this is specifically reserved to the states in the 10th Amendment.

    Maybe the Federal government has the right to spend money for the general welfare but they do not have the right to legislate it as they are trying to do through enactment of the healthcare bill. If anything, the Federal government should merely supply funds to the States and allow them to enact healthcare as they see fit for their citizens.

    Lastly, do you know of anyone that would be refused treatment if they showed up at an emergency room or state/local public clinic? Healthcare is not being denied. It may not be the level of that given to our Congress and President but it is there and available.

    The purpose of the current legislation is not to ensure healthcare for all but to take over and exact Federal control over the healthcare industry. Your original post advocated rights of the people, the healthcare plan will only further limit their choices and freedoms to choose their own destinies by an ever increasingly large “Government”.

  3. rockingjude says:

    You say, and I quote “4. Promote the general welfare – This is where I believe principle underlying equal access to health care exists. The framers understood that a country’s success was directly linked to its peoples’ general welfare, and that the government should promote that. Just as the government needed to protect its people through common defense, it needed to protect its peoples’ general welfare…”

    I say: Notice the word “promote” Not run or own…In the Bill before the house now as we speak are several devastating policies or agendas…One is that for the elderly choice of life may not be their choice anymore…just as replaced joints such as hips etc…It will be “take pain killers and move on”…
    When dying no extra measures will be taken…
    And the there is this… 20 million illegals will now be insured for FREE…Are any citizens going to get this healthcare for FREE?

    Quote: , “The problem is that in order to have a good healthcare system, you have to have ALL citizens getting healthcare, until we fill that gap, we will continue to lag behind the rest of the world.
    The number of uninsured given by your side is greatly inflated. Not counting illegal aliens, those who could have health care but choose not to have it, and those who were only temporarily without healthcare during the year in question we only have about 10 million uninsured. That is about 3% of the population. Many of them will go on to better conditions and will have health care insurance in the future. Not quite the crisis that you make it out to be.”

    Quote: “the last thing we need is a failed government trying to run a health care system…show me one government controlled pogrom that actually comes in under budget(ha) and produces results…
    remember those who work for the government bureaucracies couldn’t get real jobs where they had to actually produce. ( I served in the pentagon and white house as a Soldier, I saw them first hand)”

    Quote: “Not only will illegals be insured in the terms of this bill – they will not have to pay. If you or I can’t prove that we have an “acceptable” insurance plan then we would be automatically enrolled in the government plan and 2.5% of our salary would be deducted (against our will) to pay for individual coverage. An illegal just gets a free ride.”

    Thanks to Peter Fleckstein for pulling these out of the bill.

    “Pg 22 of the HC Bill MANDATES the Government will audit the books of ALL EMPLOYERS that self insure!!

    Pg 30 Sec 123 of HC bill – THERE WILL BE A GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE that decides what treatments and benefits you get

    Pg 29 lines 4-16 in the HC bill – YOUR HEALTHCARE IS RATIONED!!!

    Pg 42 of HC Bill – The Health Choices Commissioner will choose your HC Benefits for you. You have no choice!

    PG 50 Section 152 in HC bill – HC will be provided to ALL non US citizens, illegal or otherwise

    Pg 58HC Bill – The Government will have real-time access to individuals’ finances and a National ID Healthcard will be issued!

    Pg 59 HC Bill lines 21-24 The Government will have direct access to your bank accounts for electronic funds transfer

    PG 65 Sec 164 is a payoff; subsidized plan for retirees and their families in Unions and community organizations (ACORN).

    Pg 72 Lines 8-14 The Government is creating a HC Exchange to bring private HC plans under Government control.

    PG 84 Sec 203 HC bill – The Government mandates ALL benefit packages for private HC plans in the Exchange

    PG 85 Line 7 HC Bill – Specifies Benefit Levels for Plans = The Government will ration Your Healthcare!

    PG 91 Lines 4-7 HC Bill – The Government mandates linguistic appropriate services. Example – Translation for illegal aliens

    Pg 95 HC Bill Lines 8-18 The Government will use groups i.e., ACORN and Americorps to sign up individuals for Government HC plan

    PG 85 Line 7 HC Bill – Specifics of Benefit Levels for Plans. #AARP members – your Health care WILL be rationed

    -PG 102 Lines 12-18 HC Bill – Medicaid Eligible individuals will be automatically enrolled in Medicaid. No choice

    pg 124 lines 24-25 HC No company can sue the GOVERNMENT on price fixing. No “judicial review” against Government Monopoly

    pg 127 Lines 1-16 HC Bill – Doctors and AMA – The Government will tell YOU what you can make.

    Pg 145 Line 15-17 An Employer MUST auto enroll employees into public option plan. NO CHOICE

    Pg 126 Lines 22-25 Employers MUST pay for HC for part time employees AND their families.

    Pg 149 Lines 16-24 ANY Employers with payroll 400k and above who do not provide the public option will pay 8% tax on all payroll

    pg 150 Lines 9-13 Businesses with payroll between 251k and 400k who don’t provide the public option will pay 2-6% tax on all payroll

    Pg 167 Lines 18-23 ANY individual who doesn’t have acceptable HC according to the Government will be taxed 2.5% of income

    Pg 170 Lines 1-3 HC Bill Any NONRESIDENT Alien is exempt from individual taxes. (Americans will pay)

    Pg 195 HC Bill -officers and employees of HC Admin (GOVERNMENT) will have access to ALL Americans financial and personal records

    PG 203 Line 14-15 HC – “The tax imposed under this section shall not be treated as tax” Yes, it says that

    Pg 239 Line 14-24 HC Bill The Government will reduce physician services for Medicaid. Seniors, low income, poor affected

    Pg 241 Line 6-8 HC Bill – Doctors, it doesn’t matter what specialty you have, you’ll all be paid the same

    PG 253 Line 10-18 The Government sets value of doctor’s time, proficiency, judgment, etc. Literally the value of humans.

    PG 265 Sec 1131 The Government mandates and controls productivity for private HC industries

    PG 268 Sec 1141 Fed Government regulates rental and purchase of power driven wheelchairs

    PG 272 SEC. 1145. TREATMENT OF CERTAIN CANCER HOSPITALS – Cancer patients – welcome to rationing!

    Page 280 Sec 1151 The Government will penalize hospitals for what the Government deems preventable readmissions.

    Pg 298 Lines 9-11 Doctors, if you treat a patient during initial admission that results in a readmission-the Government will penalize you.

    Pg 317 L 13-20 OMG!! PROHIBITION on ownership and investment. The Government tells Doctors what and how much they can own.

    Pg 317-318 lines 21-25,1-3 PROHIBITION on expansion- the Government is mandating hospitals cannot expand

    pg 321 2-13 Hospitals have the option to apply for exception BUT the community input is required. Can you say ACORN?!!

    Pg335 L 16-25 Pg 336-339 – The Government mandates establishment of outcome based measures. HC the way they want. Rationing

    Pg 341 Lines 3-9 The Government has the authority to disqualify Medicare Adv Plans, HMOs, etc. Forcing people into the Government plan

    Pg 354 Sec 1177 – The Government will RESTRICT enrollment of Special needs people! WTF.

    Pg 379 Sec 1191 The Government creates more bureaucracy – Telehealth Advisory Committee. Can you say HC by phone?

    PG 425 Lines 4-12 The Government mandates Advance Care Planning Consultation. Think Senior Citizens end of life

    Pg 425 Lines 17-19 The Government will instruct and consult regarding living wills, durable powers of atty. Mandatory!

    PG 425 Lines 22-25, 426 Lines 1-3 The Government provides approved list of end of life resources, guiding you in death

    PG 427 Lines 15-24 The Government mandates a program for orders for end of life. The Government has a say in how your life ends

    Pg 429 Lines 1-9 An “adv. care planning consult” will be used frequently as patients health deteriorates

    PG 429 Lines 10-12 “adv. care consultation” may include an ORDER for end of life plans. AN ORDER from the Government

    Pg 429 Lines 13-25 – The Government will specify which Doctors can write an end of life order.

    PG 430 Lines 11-15 The Government will decide what level of treatment you will have at end of life

    Pg 469 – Community Based Home Medical Services=Non profit organizations. Hello, ACORN Medical Services here!!?

    Page 472 Lines 14-17 PAYMENT TO COMMUNITY-BASED ORGANIZATION. One monthly payment to a community-based org. Like ACORN?

    PG 489 Sec 1308 The Government will cover Marriage and Family therapy. Which means they will insert Government into your marriage

    Pg 494-498 The Government will cover Mental Health Services including defining, creating, rationing those services

    James……..here’s the rest of the list that he’s done now thru pg. 1018
    Obama Health Care Details – the first 1000 PAGES!
    PG 502 Sec 1181 Center for Comparative Effectiveness Research Established. – Hello Big Brother – Literally.
    Pg 503 Lines 13-19 Gov’t will build registries and data networks from YOUR electronic med records.
    Pg 503 lines 21-25 Gov’t may secure data directly from any depart or agency of the US including your data.
    Pg 504 Lines 6-10 The “Center” will collect data both published & unpublished (that means public & your private info)
    PG 506 Lines 19-21 The Center will recommend policies that would allow for public access of data.
    PG 518 Lines 21-25 The Commission will have input from HC consumer reps – Can you say unions & ACORN?
    PG 524 18-22 Comparative Effectiveness Research Trust Fund set up. More taxes for ALL.
    PG 621 Lines 20-25 Gov’t will define what Quality means in HC. Since when does Gov’t know about quality?
    Pg 622 Lines 2-9 To pay for the Quality Standards, Govt will transfer $$ from to other Govt Trust Funds. More Taxes.
    PG 624 “Quality” measures shall be designed to assess outcomes & functional status of patients.
    PG 624 “Quality” measures shall be designed to profile you including race, age, gender, place of residence, etc
    Pg 628 Sec 1443 Gov’t will give “Multi-Stake Holders” Pre-Rule Making input into Selection of “Quality” Measures.
    Pg 630 9-24/631 1-9 Those Multi-stake holder groups incl. Unions & groups like ACORN deciding HC quality.
    Pg 632 Lines 14-25 The Gov’t may implement any “Quality measure” of HC Services as they see fit.
    PG 633 14-25/ 634 1-9 The Secretary may issue non-endorsed “Quality Measures” for Physician Services & Dialysis Services.
    Pg 635 to 653 Physicians Payments Sunshine Provision – Gov’t wants to shine sunlight on Docs but not Govt.
    Pg 654-659 Public Reporting on Health Care-Associated Infections – Looks okay.
    PG 660-671 Doctors in Residency – Gov’t will tell you where your residency will be, thus where you’ll live.
    Pg 676-686 Gov’t will regulate hospitals in EVERY aspect of residency programs, incl. teaching hospitals.
    Pg 686-700 Increased Funding to Fight Waste, Fraud, and Abuse. You mean like the Gov’t with an $18 million website?
    PGs 701-704 Sec 1619 If your part of HC plan isn’t in Gov’t HC Exchange but you qualify for Fed aid, no payment.
    PG 705-709 SEC. 1128 If Secr gets complaints (ACORN) on HC provider or supplier, Gov’t can do background check.
    PG 711 Lines 8-14 The Secretary has broad powers to deny HC providers/suppliers admittance into HC Exchange. Your doctor could be thrown out of business.
    Pg 719-720 Sec 1637 ANY Doctor who orders durable med equip or home med services MUST be enrolled in Medicare.
    PG 722 Sec 1639 Gov’t MANDATES Doctors must have face to face with patient to certify patient for Home Health Svcs.
    PG 724 23-25 PG 725 1-5 The same Gov’t certifications will apply to Medicaid & CHIP (your kids)
    PG 724 Lines 16-22 Gov’t reserves rt to apply face to face certification for patient to ANY other HC service.
    Pg 735 lines 16-25 For law enforce. proposes the Secretary-HHS will give Atty General access to ALL data.
    PG 740-757 Gov’t sets guidelines for subsidizing the uninsured (Thats your tax dollars people)
    Pg 757-762 Fed gov’t will shift burden of payments to Disproportionate Share Hospitals (DSH) to States. (Taxes)
    Pg 763 1-8 No DS/EA hospitals will be paid unless they provide services without regard to national origin
    Pg 765 Sec 1711 Gov’t will require Preventative Services including vaccines. (Choice?)
    Pg 768 Sec 1713 Gov’t – Nurse Home Visitation Svcs (Hello union paybacks)
    Pg 769 11-14 Nurse Home Visit Svcs include-economic self-sufficiency, employ adv, school-readiness.
    Pg 769 3-5 Nurse Home Visit Services – “increasing birth intervals between pregnancies.” Govt ABORTIONS anyone
    Pg 770 SEC 1714 Fed Gov’t mandates eligibility for State Family Planning Services. Abortion & State Sovereign.
    Pg 789-797 Gov’t will set, mandate drug prices, controlling which drugs brought to market. Bye innovation.
    Pgs 797-800 SEC. 1744 PAYMENTS for graduate medical education. The government will now control Drs’ education.
    PG 801 Sec 1751 The Govt will decide which Health care conditions will be paid. Say RATION!
    Pg 810 SEC. 1759. Billing Agents, clearinghouses, etc req. to register. Gov’t takes over private payment sys.
    Pg 820-824 Sec 1801 Govt will identify individ. ineligible for subsidies. Will access all personal financial information.
    Pg 824-829 SEC. 1802. Govt Sets up Comparative Effectiveness Research Trust Fund. Another tax black hole.
    PG 829-833 Gov’t will impose a fee on ALL private health ins. plans incl. self insured to pay for Trust Fund!
    PG 835 11-13 fees imposed by Gov’t for Trust Fund shall be treated as if they were taxes.
    Pg 838-840 Gov’t will design & implement Home Visitation Program for families with young kids & families expect kids.
    PG 844-845 This Home Visitation Prog. includes Gov’t coming into your house & telling you how to parent!!!
    Pg 859 Gov’t will establish a Public Health Fund at a cost of $88,800,000,000. Yes that’s Billion.
    Pg 865 The Gov’t will MANDATE the establishment of a National Health Service Corps.
    PG 865 to 876 The NHS Corps is a program where Drs. perform mandatory HC for 2yrs for part loan repayment.
    PG 876-892 The govt takes over the education of our Med students and Drs.
    PG 898 The Govt will establish a Public Health Workforce Corps to ensure supply of public health prof.
    PG 898 The Public health workforce corps shall consist of civilian employees of the U.S. as Secretary deems.
    PG 898 The Public health workforce corps shall consist of officers of Regular & Reserve Corps of Service.
    PG 900 The Public Health Workforce Corps includes veterinarians.
    PG 901 The Public Health Workforce Corps WILL include commissioned Regular & Reserve Officers. HC Draft?
    PG 910 The Govt will develop, build & run Public Health Training Centers.
    PG 913-914 Govt starts a HC affirmative action program thru guise of diversity scholarships.
    PG 915 SEC. 2251. Govt MANDDATES Cultural & linguistic competency training for HC professionals.
    Pg 932 The Govt will estab Preventative & Wellness Trust fund- initial cost of $30,800,000,000-Billion.
    PG 935 21-22 Govt will identify specific goals & objectives for prevention & wellness activities. Control YOU!!
    PG 936 Govt will develop “Healthy People & National Public Health Perform. Standards” Tell me what to eat?
    PG 942 Lines 22-25 More Gov’t? Offices of Surgeon General -Public Health Svc, Minority Health, Women’s Health
    PG 950- 980 BIG GOV’T core pub health infrastructure including workforce capacity, lab systems; health info sys, etc
    PG 993 Gov’t will establish school based health clinics. Your kids won’t have a chance.
    PG 994 School Based Health Clinic will be integrated into the school environment. Say GOVT Brainwash!
    PG 1001 The Govt will establish a National Medical Device Registry. Will you be tracked?”

    Quote: “Myth 1. Sen. Richard Shelby, R-Ala., says that Obama risks “destroying the best health-care system the world has ever known.” In reality, it is far from the best.”
    We do in fact have a great health care system. Is it the best – no idea because you have to have a fair and universal rating system. Lets take the study health care reform advocates cite as proof the U.S. system is broken—The World Health Organization’s 2000 study which rated the U.S. as 37th in health care. Sounds pretty grim until you look at the list and see who is better than we are. Countries like Columbia, Morocco, Canada, France, Great Britain and Costa Rica to name a few. You have to be kidding if you want to use this study as proof we have a broken Health Care system! Look at the thousands coming here each month from every one of the countries listed as better the U.S. If we are so low in the ranking how come they don’t stay home? The answer is obvious- we have a superb medical system that they don’t have in their own countries. That’s the study that counts—patients vote with their feet.
    Finally, a personal story that is happening now. A restaurant worker with no insurance recently developed a kidney stone. He went to the emergency room where he was initially diagnosed and was told to go home and wait for it to pass. After a week it still had not passed and they decided to implant a stint to help pass the stone and admitted him to the hospital. As he had no insurance and a minimum wage job I was curious as to how it was going to be paid. Turns out he signed a loan agreement with payments based on his income and is being treated. I am confused by what I am being told is a crappy health care system- Here he was treated immediately and admitted to the hospital. Had he been in Canada or England under their health care system, it could have taken as long as 6 months to even be seen by a urologist. So where our system is broke and who is perpetuating the myths that it is broke?”

    Lastly this ~jude counters…If this Healthcare is so great then why is the President and ALL of congress excused from it…
    When the breakdown to actually numbers comes in it was found that within the uninsured, where
    1. People who don’t think they need to be insured…mostly young..
    2.People who are covered under their employers but have decided not to participate…
    3. People in between jobs who elected to not seek out Cobra…. there are more but will use later

    Insurance Poor and Self-Insuring: http://www.four-pillars.ca/2008/02/13/insurance-poor-and-self-insuring/

    Self insurance: http://www.abc.net.au/health/consumerguides/stories/2006/04/17/1837457.htm

    Some people think that insurance is a way of saving money. It’s not. The concept behind insurance is to cover you for unexpected large costs that might otherwise cause financial difficulty. For this, you pay a price. Health funds by and large, like any business, need to make a surplus to cover future expenses and investment. They generate more in premiums than they pay in claims – if they didn’t, they’d soon go out of business.

    Even non-profit funds generally pay only 85 to 90 per cent of premiums back to policy holders; the other 10 to 15 per cent covers administration and costs. In other words, for every hospital bill your fund covers, you are paying an additional 10 to 15 per cent in premiums. In the case of some funds it could be more.

    What if, instead of paying these premiums to the health fund, you saved them and paid the costs of any hospital and medical treatment from these accumulated savings? This is the concept of self insurance – regularly putting aside an amount towards your own ‘fund’ to cover that unexpectedly large bill. Most people would be financially better off doing this, because not only would they be keeping the additional 15 per cent , they’d also be earning interest – of say, five or six per cent – on the balance of their account.

    This would be an effective 20 per cent return on the amount that otherwise would have gone to a health fund. Another incentive for self-insuring is that you can claim a 20 per cent tax rebate on medical costs above $1500 in any financial year.

    There is a risk that you might incur a large bill in the early years of self insurance when you won’t have accumulated enough to cover the bill. And some people are just not good at saving. You would need to be prepared to use the public hospital system for emergency treatment, and even for major elective treatment (with a longer wait). But if you are disciplined about it, self insurance might make more sense for you.

    I countered you with a lot of facts rather than resorting to rhetoric… So am curious as to how you will reply=)



    • Brian says:

      Jude, I appreciate your vigor, but the sheer length of your comment obviates a rebuttal. I simply don’t have time to address this point by point.

  4. Brian says:

    First of all, what our ancestors did is of little importance. We live in a different world, with different problems. The health of a population depends on many factors, one of which is access to affordable health care. Many people in this country have little or no access to health care because they simply cannot afford insurance, or their employer does not offer it.

    You said: “Government according to the original Constitution was to leave us with as many freedoms as possible…It was NOT meant to take care of the people except in the time of defending our country.”

    This is simply incorrect. Read the preamble to the US Constitution, which outlines the purpose of the document underlying our government:

    “We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.”

    Some pretty straightforward issues there:

    1. We the people: this equals democracy, government of, by and for the people.

    2. “Establish Justice” – Justice and fairness go hand in hand with equality.

    3. Common defense: you touched on that, correctly.

    4. Promote the general welfare – This is where I believe principle underlying equal access to health care exists. The framers understood that a country’s success was directly linked to its peoples’ general welfare, and that the government should promote that. Just as the government needed to protect its people through common defense, it needed to protect its peoples’ general welfare.

    5. To Secure the Blessings of Liberty: This is the freedom part. How can anyone in this country be free when so many are oppressed by a system that does not provide for their general welfare? The country stands a better chance of collapsing if we neglect to provide for the peoples’ general welfare!

    This isn’t about government controlling people’s lives, it’s about providing for the people’s general welfare so that they may be free to pursue happiness with life and liberty!

  5. rockingjude says:

    What did our ancestors do?
    Life needs to be simplified now and people need to become self reliant on themselves…
    Government according to the original Constitution was to leave us with as many freedoms as possible…It was NOT meant to take care of the people except in the time of defending our country[notice she doesn’t say the world!].

    The more government comes in and controls our lives the more freedoms we lose. History ALWAYS repeats itself and so we are seeing the decline of an empire…One unable to sustain to maintain it’s population base or it’s culture.

    Defense….that was one of the government’s duties through it’s people…this is a tough one..think of Blackwater…Control of any identity at this point in time leaves that control in the hands of those who have the money and power, just as they control the government..

    Which is why it is so important to not go with the NWO and put control into even a fewer amount of people.
    I know this doesn’t directly answer your question but at this point unless there is a revolution whether spiritual/physical I feel that it[the question] as many other questions are redundant…
    Looking to see if I lapsed into twitter speak, but hey looks OK!!…TY very much for asking my opinion for what it is worth… ))


  6. Brian Sibley says:

    You’ve been blog-tagged on my blog!

  7. Brian Sibley says:

    Thanks for blog-tagging me – finally found out about it and have responded…


    The Other Brian Sibley

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: